Research

Employer seals and applicant behavior

What my doctoral research found about employer seals in Germany – from a market analysis of more than 60 seals to a randomized experiment with 1,093 participants.

Seals and awards appear on countless job ads and careers pages. When I began my doctoral research, two basic questions had no solid answer: how are these seals actually awarded, and do candidates care whether a company has one? My PhDr. dissertation at DTI University, completed in September 2024, looks at both.

The dissertation

The thesis is titled “Marktanalyse bestehender Gütesiegel für Arbeitgeber in Deutschland: Eine Einordnung nach Vergabeverfahren und Messung des Einflusses von Arbeitgebersiegeln auf das Bewerberverhalten”. In English, roughly: a market analysis of the employer seals that exist in Germany, classified by how they are awarded, together with a measurement of how employer seals influence applicant behavior. The work has two parts.

Part 1: How more than 60 employer seals are awarded

The first part maps the market. I analyzed more than 60 employer seals available in Germany and classified them by the procedure behind them. That is exactly what an applicant cannot tell from the logo alone: who awards the seal, on what basis, and what a company has to do to receive it.

Press coverage picked up this point. HR-Insider reported that employer seals are often not transparent, and in OnPulson I put it this way: when a seal is simply offered for sale, people should become suspicious.

Part 2: A randomized experiment with 1,093 participants

The second part tests whether a seal changes how likely people are to apply. 1,093 participants with a representative age distribution were randomly assigned to one of two groups of 548 and 545 people. Both groups saw the same job ad. The only difference: one version showed no seal, the other showed a “Top Arbeitgeber” (top employer) seal.

Participants then rated on a scale from 0 to 10 how likely they would be to apply for the job. Ratings from 8 to 10 counted as likely to apply.

Result Job ad without seal Job ad with seal
Likely to apply (8–10) 37.96% 53.95%
Unlikely to apply 17.88% 6.04%

With the seal, the share of people who said they would likely apply rose by about 16 percentage points. The share of clearly unwilling candidates fell to roughly a third of its original level.

Transparency note: The seal used in the experiment is awarded by the DIQP (Deutsches Institut für Qualitätsstandards und -prüfung). I am a member of the DIQP’s Scientific Advisory Board.

What the results mean, and what they don’t

The experiment tested one seal on one job ad. It shows that a visible seal can make the same ad noticeably more attractive. It cannot show that every seal on the market has the same effect. That is why the first part of the research, the question of how a seal is awarded, matters just as much as the second.

For employers, this leads to a simple test before choosing a seal: what exactly is assessed, by whom, and can the company explain it to a candidate in one or two sentences? My recruiting guide covers employer seals in more detail, together with employee surveys and the EmpCo Directive.

Publications

  • 2025Effect of Employer Seals on Potential Applicants: How Do Seals of Quality Work and How Have Applicants’ Requirements Changed in Recent YearsStudy, March 2025 · ResearchGate
  • 2024Employer Branding: A Comprehensive Guide for U.S. EmployersArticle, December 2024 · ResearchGate
  • 2024Influence of Employer Quality Seals on Applicant Behavior: A Comprehensive ReviewArticle, December 2024 · International Journal of Progressive Research in Engineering Management and Science
  • 2024Impact of Seals of Quality on Consumer Behavior: An Analysis of the Influence of Seals of Quality on the Willingness of Customers to Pay When Shopping OnlineArticle, December 2024 · International Journal of Progressive Research in Engineering Management and Science
  • 2024How to Attract New Employees to Your Company: What Do Generations X, Y and Z Want from an Employer?Article, November 2024 · ResearchGate
  • 2024How American Companies Are Becoming More Family-Friendly: The Importance of Family-Friendliness in Attracting Skilled WorkersArticle, October 2024 · ResearchGate
  • 2024How to Be a Top Employer: A Guide for U.S. EmployersArticle, September 2024 · ResearchGate
  • 2024Marktanalyse bestehender Gütesiegel für Arbeitgeber in DeutschlandDoctoral dissertation (PhDr.), September 2024 · DTI University
  • 2023Studie: ArbeitgebersiegelStudy, January 2023 · ResearchGate

All publications are listed on ResearchGate and Google Scholar.

Want to discuss the findings or use them for your employer brand? I am happy to talk about the study, its method and what it means in practice.